Paradise or Peril? The Great AI Debate

Exploring the two visions of our AI future

Welcome to AI for the Rest of Us! We’re thrilled to have you here.

If you’re reading this, you’re either a free subscriber or not a subscriber at all, so you currently do not get the full newsletter (😢).

We’re sad too, so we’re considering a change that would get you the full thing without paying. The change would involve ads – which basically means you’d get the full newsletter every week, with a few ads sprinkled in.

We’d love to know what you think about that, so we have a very simple poll:

Do you want to get the full version of the newsletter with ads?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

If you mark “It depends,” would you please send us an email at [email protected] to expound on the answer? Lovely. Thank you. We’ll update you on the results.

OK, for this week’s newsletter, we’re talking about the prevailing two visions of our AI future: Utopia vs Dystopia. On one end, we’ve got the AI Doomers who warn of existential risks and job displacement. On the other, the AI Optimists who envision a future of unprecedented abundance and human flourishing. And it seems like everyone’s picked a side.

These opposing camps have grown increasingly vocal over the past few years – especially in recent months, thanks to major technological breakthroughs and a new administration in the White House.

Yes, there are many people in the middle, and no, I’m not wanting to sensationalize things by talking about the extremes. But I believe we can learn a lot from them, so that’s what we’re gonna do.

We hope you’ll jump in with us by becoming a premium member (or marking “Absolutely” on the poll). And as always, you can listen to an AI podcast of this edition to give you a taste of what you’d get with the full thing.

– Kyser

Let’s Learn Something

The AI Divide: Optimists vs. Doomers 
When it comes to AI, most people close to the technology seem to fall into two camps:

AI Optimists 
These folks believe AI will usher in an era of unprecedented human flourishing. The term was mostly made famous by Marc Andreessen in his Techno-Optimist Manifesto. Optimists see AI as the solution to humanity’s biggest challenges – from curing diseases to solving climate change. They also argue that AI will create more jobs than it eliminates and ultimately lead to abundance for all.

Some of the key people are Andreessen himself, Sam Altman of OpenAI, Eric Schmidt, former Google CEO, and really most people in tech. The current administration is in this camp, and this is important to know as we explore geopolitical topics in upcoming editions (e.g. What’s up with China and AI?).

AI Accelerationists (e/acc): This is a subset of Optimists who believe we should develop AI as quickly as possible with minimal restrictions. Their philosophy is essentially “faster is safer” – arguing that the benefits of rapid AI development far outweigh the risks, and that slowing down actually creates more danger by giving bad actors an advantage. You hear this talking point quite frequently right now.

AI Doomers 
On the flip side, Doomers warn about existential risks and the societal disruption that AI could bring. They point to massive job displacement, the potential for autonomous weapons, and ultimately, the risk of creating superintelligent systems that might act against human interests.

Notable voices here are Gary Marcus, philosopher Nick Bostrom, and even some industry insiders like Geoffrey Hinton, considered one of the “godfathers of AI,” who left Google to speak out more freely about AI risks.

AI Decelerationists (Decels): This is a subset of Doomers who specifically advocate for slowing down AI development through regulations, moratoriums, and safety standards. They believe we need more time to align AI systems with human values before pushing the technology further.

In the Know

The rest of the newsletter is for premium members only. Consider upgrading to view this edition and all previous ones on our website. And starting in two weeks, you’ll get the full newsletter in your inbox every other Friday.

Or better yet, if you want the full thing with ads without paying anything, click “Absolutely” in the poll above!

Whatever you decide, you can upgrade or downgrade at any point, or you can stick with free until you’re ready to join. We’re just glad to have you part of the community. Check us out on Instagram for news, content, and fun stuff. BTW, we explain on the website why we do paid memberships – just click here and scroll down to the FAQs.

AI in the Wild

This section is for premium members only.

It’s Play Time

Newcomers [AI is new to me]

This section is for premium members only.

Explorers [I’m comfortable with AI]

This section is for premium members only.

That wraps up another edition of AI for the Rest of Us. Before you go, I’d love to hear what you thought about this edition. Just hit reply and let me know if you’ve got feedback or thoughts on how to make AI for the Rest of Us better for you.

Until next time...

Reply

or to participate.